Skip links

Casey Cay Resort Beachfront Accommodations

Casey Cay Beachfront features incredible views and easy access to the Gulf of Mexico beach. Fully renovated inside and out, this beachside relaxation destination is quiet and exclusive. Lounge under the iconic striped umbrellas on the beach, or enjoy a swing in the hammock on a warm tropical day.

WELCOME TO CASA CAY!

These three perfect Beach Rentals have access to both the beautiful Gulf of Mexico and the Back Bay on small island paradise just south of Siesta Key. Casa Cay is an intimate friendly place to relax and unwind as you watch dolphins at play, manatee, pelicans, shorebirds wildlife all waiting to entertain you. Here you bask in the simple pleasures of island life, walking the beach, shelling, searching for sharks’ teeth, or enjoy the cultural communities of Venice to the south or Sarasota to the north both just minutes away. Take an unforgettable drive or bike ride down Casey Key Road and see some of Sarasota’s most luxurious homes. Casa Cay offers a charming two-bedroom two bath beach house and two fully equipped efficiencies. Rent one or all three to vacation with your group or family. Please explore each unit above to the accommodations and amenities Casa Cay offers you.

Subscribe and take 20% off your first order!

Testimonials

Jorden

Jorden

August 2023

Dear Casa Cay Employes & Owners, We absolutely enjoyed our stay here at your beach get-away! This place will be recommended to all family & friends. We look for ward to coming back in the future ourselves! Here is a new shell to add to your shelf 🙂 A vacation we will Never forget!
Mark

Mark

January 2023

Fantastic location and accommodations. Steps to one of the most beautiful beaches in the world perfect for shelling, swimming, or walking. The unit was immaculate and well equipped. I appreciated the little touches like a wash cloth for make-up and good quality extra blankets. We were 100% satisfied, and hope to return during another season.
Jessica

Jessica

July 2023

When booking this home for our trip, I literally wanted to be ON the beach. This place was exactly what I was looking for. Not even a 1 minute walk to the beach. Lots of shells, warm clear water, and a secluded area. We were able to watch a rocket launch from the spiral stairs in the middle of the night, gaze at the stars on the beach at night, and watch the turtles nest. This BnB is a quick drive to Venice for shopping and Manisota beach for Shark teeth hunting. Will definitely be back to Nokomis for another trip.
Brandon

Brandon

July 2023

Awesome place right on the beach. Great location and awesome deal. Really enjoyed watching the sunset from the hammock.
Diane

Diane

July 2023

My best friend and I brought our granddaughters to Troy's beach cottage for a couple of nights and it was just what the doctor ordered. The only problem was we needed more time!! Our unit was basically one big room with 2 comfy queen beds and a pull out sofa bed so we could have a slumber party both nights. The kitchen has everything you need. The bathroom has been remodeled and has plenty of hot water. The A/C is cold. We were situated beach side and only had a short walk through the complex and sea oats to get to one of Florida's loveliest beaches. It is semi-private there and so there's plenty of room to stretch out and listen to the birds and the waves instead of someone's blasting boom box. The local ice cream shop (Mellissa's) was delicious. We loved our stay...we'll be back! Thanks Troy!!!
DIANE
★★★★★ 5/5

My best friend and I brought our granddaughters to Troy's beach cottage for a couple of nights and it was just what the doctor ordered. The only problem was we needed more time!! Our unit was basically one big room with 2 comfy queen beds and a pull out sofa bed so we could have a slumber party both nights. The kitchen has everything you need. The bathroom has been remodeled and has plenty of hot water. The A/C is cold. We were situated beach side and only had a short walk through the complex and sea oats to get to one of Florida's loveliest beaches. It is semi-private there and so there's plenty of room to stretch out and listen to the birds and the waves instead of someone's blasting boom box. The local ice cream shop (Mellissa's) was delicious. We loved our stay...we'll be back! Thanks Troy!!!

Diane July 2023

BRANDON
★★★★★ 5/5

Awesome place right on the beach. Great location and awesome deal. Really enjoyed watching the sunset from the hammock.

Brandon July 2023

JESSICA
★★★★★ 5/5

When booking this home for our trip, I literally wanted to be ON the beach. This place was exactly what I was looking for. Not even a 1 minute walk to the beach. Lots of shells, warm clear water, and a secluded area. We were able to watch a rocket launch from the spiral stairs in the middle of the night, gaze at the stars on the beach at night, and watch the turtles nest. This BnB is a quick drive to Venice for shopping and Manisota beach for Shark teeth hunting. Will definitely be back to Nokomis for another trip.

Jessica July 2023

MARK
★★★★★ 5/5

Fantastic location and accommodations. Steps to one of the most beautiful beaches in the world perfect for shelling, swimming, or walking. The unit was immaculate and well equipped. I appreciated the little touches like a wash cloth for make-up and good quality extra blankets. We were 100% satisfied, and hope to return during another season.

Mark January 2023

JORDEN
★★★★★ 5/5

Dear Casa Cay Employes & Owners, We absolutely enjoyed our stay here at your beach get-away! This place will be recommended to all family & friends. We look for ward to coming back in the future ourselves! Here is a new shell to add to your shelf 🙂 A vacation we will Never forget!

Jorden Augest 2023